Research
Italy's under-13 social-media account ban remains a proposed amendment—not enacted law—that would also require parent-linked accounts for ages 13-15 and independent access from 16, with age-verification rules still undrafted by regulator AGCOM. The core tension is that rigorous evidence (National Academies, EU JRC, Orben & Przybylski) finds only small, mixed harms from social media at the population level, while Australia's early under-16 ban experience shows account ownership dropping sharply without a proportional drop in actual platform use—suggesting exclusion and exposure aren't the same thing. A deeper unresolved conflict pits proponents' precautionary "ban now" logic against critics (Italy's own privacy regulator, UNICEF, EU Kids Online researchers) who favor enforceable platform safety-by-design and warn that parental-linkage requirements may disproportionately burden lower-income or less digitally cap
# Italy set to introduce social media curbs for teenagers ROME, Nov 18 (Reuters) - Italy is set to become the latest country to restrict access to social media for minors, following the example of countries such as Australia, Brazil and Greece, with parliament expected to approve a government decree by end-year. • Children below the age of 13 will be barred from having social media accounts. • Minors aged 13-15 will be allowed them only if they are linked to the accounts of one of their parents • Independent accounts will be permitted from age 16 • The measures are contained in an amendment to a security decree under discussion in parliament and due to be approved by late December • The amendment, seen by Reuters, has yet to be formally presented but is backed by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's right-wing coalition ... • Under its current form, which may be tweaked during parliamentary discussions, the proposed law exempts educational apps from the ban • It says social media companies will have to verify their users' age, following guidelines to be drafted by Italian telecoms regulator AGCOM within nine months of the entry into force of the decree
# Parental controls for under-16s: Italy is preparing restrictions on social media Italy is preparing to tighten the rules on social media use for minors. Giorgia Meloni’s government has backed an initiative that will ban children under the age of 13 from creating accounts, whilst allowing teenagers under the age of 16 to use the platforms only under parental supervision. ... The relevant provisions are included in an amendment to the security decree, which is currently being considered by parliament. The document is expected to be approved by the end of December. According to parliamentary sources, it is highly likely to be adopted. Under the proposed rules, children under the age of 13 will be completely banned from creating social media accounts. Teenagers aged between 13 and 15 will only be able to use the platforms via accounts linked to their parents’ profiles. Independent registration will be permitted from the age of 16. The amendment, which has been seen by Reuters, has not yet been officially tabled. However, it is supported by the centre-right coalition led by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. ... The proposed restrictions will not apply to educational apps. However, owners of social media platforms will be required to implement age verification for users. Specific requirements for such a system will be drawn up by the Italian communications regulator, AGCOM, within nine months of the decree coming into force.
Children aged 13 to 15 would be able to use social media through an account managed by a parent or guardian, and kids would be able to open and manage their own social media accounts once they turn 16.
# Ruling coalition presenting measure to ban social media for under 13s Premier Giorgia Meloni's ruling centre-right coalition is presenting an amendment to the government's latest security decree which would ban under 13s from accessing social media services in Italy. Children aged 13 to 15 would be able to use social media through an account managed by a parent or guardian, and kids would be able to open and manage their own social media accounts once they turn 16.
## Italy Moves to Ban Social Media for Children Under 13 The government aims to pass the law by the end of November, requiring parental-linked accounts for teens ages 13 to 15 and allowing independent access at 16. ... ROME — The Italian government is moving to fast-track a ban on social media for children under 13, aiming to pass the legislation by the end of November. The ruling coalition is preparing an amendment to a security bill currently under consideration in the House. The proposed rules would prohibit social media accounts for children under 13, require users ages 13 to 15 to access platforms through accounts linked to their parents’ profiles, and allow independent access starting at 16. The amendment is expected to be introduced Nov. 18. ... For months, however, the bill stalled in the Senate as the government weighed whether to move ahead with the measure through a decree. ... ### Meta Fined €805 Million in Italy Over Facebook Access to Users’ Photos and Videos She also defended the bipartisan proposal, which she said had been ready for months and already notified to Brussels, accusing the government of having “opposed it and blocked it in Parliament.” ... The proposal has not yet become law.
Premier Giorgia Meloni's ruling centre-right coalition is presenting an amendment to the government's latest security decree which would ban under 13s from accessing social media services in Italy. Children aged 13 to 15 would be able to use social media through an account managed by a parent or guardian, and kids would be able to open and manage their own social media accounts once they turn 16.
# Italy plans to introduce social media restrictions for teenagers — from what age The Italian parliament may restrict social media for minors by the end of the year. Until the age of 16, accounts will require parental control. ... Parliament is expected to approve the relevant government decree by the end of the year, **UNN** reports, citing Reuters. ## Details Children under the age of 13 will be prohibited from having social media accounts. Minors aged 13 to 15 will be allowed to use them only if their accounts are linked to one of their parents’ accounts. Creating independent accounts will be permitted from the age of 16. These measures are contained in an amendment to the security decree, which is currently being discussed in parliament and is to be approved by the end of December. The amendment, whose text was reviewed by Reuters, has not yet been officially presented, but it has already received the support of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s right-wing coalition. ... According to the current version of the document (which may still be changed during parliamentary debates), the ban will not apply to educational apps. ... Companies that own social media platforms are expected to be required to verify the ages of their users. This verification will be carried out in accordance with guidelines to be developed by Italy’s telecommunications regulator (AGCOM) within nine months after the decree takes effect.
# Italy set to introduce social media curbs for teenagers ons 18.11.2026 13:02 ... ROME, Nov 18 (Reuters) - Italy is set to become the latest country to restrict access to social media for minors, following the example of countries such as Australia, Brazil and Greece, with parliament expected to approve a government decree by end-year. • Children below the age of 13 will be barred from having social media accounts. • Minors aged 13-15 will be allowed them only if they are linked to the accounts of one of their parents • Independent accounts will be permitted from age 16 • The measures are contained in an amendment to a security decree under discussion in parliament and due to be approved by late December • The amendment, seen by Reuters, has yet to be formally presented but is backed by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's right-wing coalition • It is almost certain to be approved, parliamentary sources say ... • Under its current form, which may be tweaked during parliamentary discussions, the proposed law exempts educational apps from the ban • It says social media companies will have to verify their users' age, following guidelines to be drafted by Italian telecoms regulator AGCOM within nine months of the entry into force of the decree
New rules provide restrictions for minors, linking teenagers' accounts to parental profiles, and mandatory age verification. ... Italy plans to introduce age restrictions on the use of social networks for children and teenagers. A corresponding amendment to the security decree is being discussed in parliament. The document is expected to receive majority support and be adopted by the end of December 2026. ... From what age will social networks be allowed The proposed rules provide for three age categories of users: children under 13 will be prohibited from creating social media accounts; teenagers aged 13 to 15 will be able to use platforms only if their accounts are linked to one of their parents' accounts; from 16 years old, users will be allowed to have their own independent accounts. The current version of the amendment also provides an exception for educational applications. They will not fall under the proposed ban. At the same time, the document may still change during parliamentary discussions. ... A separate provision of the amendment concerns the responsibility of companies that own social networks. They will have to implement age verification for their users. The relevant requirements will be developed by the Italian telecommunications regulator AGCOM. It will be given nine months to prepare instructions after the decree comes into force. The amendment has not yet been officially presented, but it is supported by the ruling coalition of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. According to sources in parliament, the document will almost certainly receive the necessary support.
# Today in Italy: A roundup of the latest news on Thursday Published: 19 Nov, 2026 CET. ... “Today, we have entered a new phase – one that is more advanced, more pervasive and more insidious”, Crosetto told parliament in a briefing, referencing a series of cyberattacks and bomb threats that have targeted Italy in recent weeks. ... Italy’s government on Wednesday presented plans to ban social media for under-13s and restrict access for under-16s via an amendment to its latest security bill, currently before the lower house’s justice committee. Under the planned rule change, the accounts of 13-16-year-olds would be linked to their parents’ accounts, in line with incoming EU restrictions announced in September, Il Corriere della Sera newspaper reported. ### Advertisement Brussels in October imposed a moratorium on EU member states moving forward with their own regulations while its Kids Act is reviewed by parliament, but Italy was granted an exemption due to having already presented a bipartisan bill on the issue last year.
## For young people aged between 13 and 16, social media accounts will only be permitted if managed by a parent. The proposal will be presented to the Chamber of Deputies. The decree also provides for new measures to tackle juvenile crime and violence at demonstrations ... No social media for children under 13. For young people aged between 13 and 16, however, access is only permitted via an account managed by a parent. The majority is preparing new restrictions on the use of digital platforms by young people, through an amendment to the decree-law on public safety and the fight against juvenile crime, which is currently being examined by the Chamber of Deputies. The proposal is expected to be tabled by 18 November, the deadline for submitting amendments. The legislation has not yet been approved and will have to pass parliamentary scrutiny. ... The proposal distinguishes between two age groups. Children under the age of 13 would be barred from accessing social media. Those aged between 13 and 16, on the other hand, would be able to use the platforms via an account managed by a parent. The aim is to strengthen control over minors’ access to digital services by giving families a direct role in managing their children’s profiles. However, the practical details still need to be clarified, particularly with regard to age verification, parental controls and any obligations placed on the platforms.
MILAN, Nov 19 (Reuters) - A Milan court on Thursday put off until January 21 its decision in a case brought by a group of Italian families seeking to restrict minors’ access to Meta and TikTok, as the government prepares its own curbs. Judges had been expected to rule on Thursday but postponed the hearing until January 21, lawyers involved in the case said, after the Italian government said on Wednesday it expected parliament to approve a decree restricting minors’ access to social media by the end of the year. ... The plans include an amendment to a security decree, proposed earlier this week by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s ruling coalition, that would bar children under 13 from holding social media accounts.
# Stop to social media for under 13s, amendment to Security Decree ready ... November 17, 2026 ... Rome, 17 Nov. (Adnkronos) – The center-right is ready to present to the Chamber an amendment to the Security Decree which introduces an absolute ban on the use of social networks for children up to 13 years of age. The text takes up the bill developed by two parliamentarians, Lavinia Mennuni of Fratelli d’Italia and Marianna Madia of Italia Viva, which had already been notified to the EU Commission. The announcement should be made official tomorrow by the majority. After “months of work, discussions, hearings – Senator Mennuni tells Adnkronos – finally the Italian Parliament will approve a law that provides for a regulation for minors’ access to social networks”. “I am proud that this work for the Mennuni-Madia bill, signed together with the members of the Bicameral Commission for Childhood and Adolescence and all parliamentary groups, will quickly turn into a concrete law.”
# Social media and minors: Italy is nearing a turning point: "A total ban for those under 13." Majority amendment to the security bill. And children aged 13 to 16 will only be able to manage one if it's linked to their parents' account. ... **A complete ban on social media for children up to the age of 13, a more relaxed ban for children between the ages of 13 and 16, who will not be able to have their own account but will be able to manage one linked to their parents'** , while those aged 16 and over will have full freedom to join a social media platform. The rule, developed with decisive input from Palazzo Chigi, will be presented in the next few hours by all majority group leaders as an amendment to the security decree; an amendment that, it is understood, will be open to contributions and modifications. ... **Education Minister Giuseppe Valditara, who has long been calling for a crackdown** , is rejoicing, also supported by what international studies are attesting: cell phones negatively impact learning, causing problems with attention, concentration, memory, and difficulty studying. Psychologists from AUPI, the United Association of Italian Psychologists, also applauded the initiative: "Scientific evidence," they emphasize, "shows us how important it is to protect children and adolescents from the risks associated with early and unregulated use of digital platforms."
Social media ban for under-13s: Meloni wants it included in the security decree; it will become law by the end of the month - la Repubblica ... # Social media ban for under-13s: Meloni wants it included in the security decree; it will become law by the end of the month ... Majority amendment ready: a total ban for the youngest children. For those aged 13 to 16, the option to manage an account linked to their parents’. The framework of the European Kids Act will be followed 17 November 2026 Updated at 21:07 2 min read
# Review: Social media use and adolescent mental health - an umbrella review and power analysis ## Abstract Across reviews, general SMU showed weak and inconsistent associations with both well-being and ill-being, while problematic SMU was consistently linked to ill-being.
# Social media: Age-related bans won’t keep kids safe, UNICEF warns The ban aims to protect young people from online abuse such as cyberbullying, exploitation and exposure to harmful content, all of which are detrimental to their mental health and well-being. ## Bans could backfire As other governments contemplate similar moves, the UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF) cautions that age-related restrictions alone won’t keep children safe. “While UNICEF welcomes the growing commitment to children’s online safety, **social media bans come with their own risks, and they may even backfire**,” the agency said in a statement. For many children, particularly those who are isolated or marginalised, social media is a lifeline for learning, connection, play and self-expression, UNICEF explained. Moreover, many will still access social media – for example, through workarounds, shared devices, or use of less regulated platforms – which will only make it harder to protect them. ## Protection and respect for human rights “**Age restrictions must be part of a broader approach** that protects children from harm, respects their rights to privacy and participation, and avoids pushing them into unregulated, less safe spaces,” the statement said. “Regulation should not be a substitute for platforms investing in child safety. Laws introducing age restrictions are not an alternative to companies improving platform design and content moderation.” ... ## Make the internet safe UNICEF urges governments, regulators and tech companies to work together with children and families to build a digital space that is safe, inclusive and respects children’s rights. **Authorities must ensure that age-related laws and regulations do not replace companies’ obligations to invest in safer platform design** and effective content moderation. ... ## Support for parents “But it is also very clear from a human rights perspective that the best interest of the child has to be taken into account in all of this, including the protection and safety concerns that children face.”
# Age restrictions alone won’t keep children safe online, says UNICEF **KUALA LUMPUR, 12 December 2025** – UNICEF today reaffirmed that while governments are right to take online child sexual exploitation and abuse seriously, social media age bans on their own will not keep children safe online and may have unintended consequences. ... At the same time, UNICEF cautions that age restrictions and bans must be part of a broader approach, not a standalone solution. ... “But simply banning younger users from social media will not solve the problem. Many children will still find ways to go online, often through less regulated platforms, where it is harder to protect them and they will be less likely to seek help when something goes wrong.” ... Digital platforms can provide vital opportunities for learning, connection, play and self-expression. Any measure to protect children must therefore balance safety with their rights to participation, information and privacy.
The meta-analysis (conducted in R software) of the included documents (24 studies, 68 effects) verified a significant and positive association between exposure to risk factors in social networks and various disorders in adolescents and young adults (aggregate correlation *r* = 0.2173, 95% CI [0.1826, 0.2520], *p* ≤ 0.0001), although with high heterogeneity (*I* ^2^ = 99.66%). ... Despite the robustness of the association, the predominance of cross-sectional designs (79%) limits causal inference. ... Future research should prioritize longitudinal and experimental designs to disentangle causal relations and identify high-risk subgroups.
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2024. *Social Media and Adolescent Health*. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. doi: 10.17226/27396. ... Suggested citation: National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2024. *Social media and adolescent health*. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/27396. ... # Preface The committee recognized that the temptation to draw causal inference and to call for rapid action around social media is strong, and heard, during public session, from a range of academics and activists who feel strongly that causal links between social media and mental health have been unequivocally established and that there is an urgent need for action. ... The science suggests that some features of social media function can harm some young people’s mental health. These include, but are not limited to, algorithmically driven distortions of reality exacerbating harmful content and disinformation, the distraction away from time that can otherwise be used in more healthy ways, and the creation of opportunities where youth can be abused or exploited. However, there are also several ways in which social media improve the lives of youth, including the creation of opportunities for community among more marginalized youth, and the opportunity for fun and joy for the vast majority of users. This balance lies at the heart of the relation between social media and mental health. While some users, using social media in particular ways, may have their mental health adversely affected, for many others there will be no such harm, and for others still the experience will be helpful. ... The committee’s recommendations include recommendations to develop industry standards that can ensure social media use protects mental health in the long term, the engagement of educators and health care providers in highlighting the benefits, and minimizing the harms of social media use, and specific measures to protect youth from online abuse. The committee also recommends a doubling down on research that can lead to better clarity about the causal links between aspects of social media and mental health, to the end of pointing to more specific actions that can mitigate the harms, and accentuate the positives, of social media.
While age-based restrictions may play a role, they are unlikely on their own to bring about the necessary changes in the technology industry to support children’s rights and safety online. ... However, debates continue over the evidence regarding risks and harm, with some suggesting that ‘bans’ oversimplify the complex impacts of social media on children. Others worry that age restrictions may drive children toward less-regulated online spaces and do little to hold technology companies accountable for considering children’s rights in the design and operation of their platforms. ... There is not yet consensus on the psychological, emotional, and cognitive factors that should be prioritised when considering the appropriate age for access to social media.
WASHINGTON — A new report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine offers nearly a dozen recommendations for social media companies, Congress, the U.S. Department of Education, and others to minimize the harm of social media use on adolescents’ health while maximizing its benefits. ... The report concludes there is not enough evidence to say that social media causes changes in adolescent health at the population level, but research shows social media has the potential to both harm and benefit adolescent health. Much of the research into the connections between social media and adolescent health cannot distinguish the direction of the relationship between the two, as social media may influence health, but health may also influence how young people use social media. Most research also cannot establish if that relationship is causal, or capture individual differences among adolescents. ... Despite many years of research, the evidence clarifying precisely how social media influences health is limited, the report says. The rigorous study designs that would shed light on the extent to which social media causes harms are severely lacking. ... - Understanding causal directions between social media use and adolescent health. ... - Understanding causal directions between social media use and adolescent health.
Assessment of the Impact of Social Media on the Health and Wellbeing of Adolescents and Children ... This study will examine the current research and make conclusions about the impact of social media on the mental and physical health and wellbeing of adolescents and children. ... Consensus Study Report ... An ad hoc committee of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine will examine the current research and make conclusions about the impact of social media on the mental and physical health and wellbeing of adolescents and children. ... The committee should identify what is needed in a research agenda to more fully understand the impact of social media on adolescents, children and their families, as well as the data that would be required in order to comprehensively evaluate the effects of social media products on the mental and physical health and wellbeing of adolescents and children. The committee should also make recommendations for steps that parents, social media companies, and public officials can take to maximize potential benefits and minimize potential harms of social media for adolescents and children. ... # Social Media and Adolescent Health 2024 ... Social media has been fully integrated into the lives of most adolescents in the U.S., raising concerns among parents, physicians, public health officials, and others about its effect on mental and physical health. Over the past year, an ad hoc committee of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine examined the research and produced this detailed report exploring that effect and laying out recommendations for policymakers, regulators, industry, and others in an effort to maximize the good and minimize the bad. ... National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2024. *Social Media and Adolescent Health*. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
# Social Media Trap: A Systematic Review of the Content and Pathways that Affect Adolescents’ Mental Health - Published: 15 March 2025 ... The purpose of this systematic review is to synthesize the evidence on the relationship between social media content and adolescents’ mental health. ... The review included 32 studies. The results suggest that teen use of social media is associated with several poor mental health outcomes, such as depression, loneliness, anxiety, and low self-esteem. Anxiety and depression were the two most prevalent mental health issues. Image-related content on social media was the main factor affecting the mental health of teenagers. Extended screen time and cyberbullying were the most commonly reported pathways through which social media content affects adolescents’ mental health.
Amidst rising concerns about mental health in adolescents, the role of social media (SM), particularly highly visual platforms such as TikTok, has become a growing focus of investigation. In the extant literature, conclusive evidence is limited by the aggregate analysis of very heterogeneous SM platforms. This systematic scoping review examines the relationship between TikTok and mental health in adolescents.
Social media use and youth mental health and well-being: a systematic review of longitudinal and experimental evidence This review synthesises longitudinal and experimental evidence on social media use and well-being or mental health among adolescents and emerging adults, identifying 55 studies from 4,188 records through a PRISMA-based process (41 longitudinal and 14 experimental studies). Overall, the evidence does not support a single uniform association between social media use and poorer mental health across all young people: findings based on time- or frequency-based measures are mixed, often small, and sensitive to modelling choices, while reverse or bidirectional pathways remain plausible in some contexts. More consistent associations are found for problematic or dysregulated use, negative consequences, and harmful online experiences, although these measures also require cautious interpretation where they overlap conceptually with distress or impairment. Experimental evidence is informative for short-run, mechanism-linked outcomes, particularly appearance-related self-evaluative outcomes; evidence for FoMO is more conditional, and broader symptom changes are less consistent across studies and intervention designs. For policy, approaches focused only on reducing time online are likely to be imprecise unless they also consider dysregulated engagement, harmful online experiences, and specific risk pathways such as social comparison, appearance pressures and sleep disruption.
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine; Health and Medicine Division; Board on Population Health and Public Health Practice; Committee on the Impact of Social Media on Adolescent Health; Wojtowicz A, Buckley GJ, Galea S, editors. Social Media and Adolescent Health. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2024 Mar 25. ... There are several reasons why these links between social media and health are complex. First, the direction of the relationship is difficult to determine, as social media may influence a health outcome and health may influence social media use. ... The bias introduced by omitted variables makes it difficult to say to what extent a young person’s health problems are the cause or the effect of social media use or of another unmeasured cause. ... The committee’s review of the literature did not support the conclusion that social media causes changes in adolescent health at the population level. ... The standard of evidence needed to establish a causal relation between an outcome and exposure is high. Most of the research on this topic has established only an association between social media use and different mental and physical health outcomes. Evidence of such associations is useful and can drive hypothesis formation and further inquiry, but it is not sufficient, on balance, to lead this committee to recommend additional restrictions on young people’s access to social media. ... Special emphasis should be given to study designs that attempt to understand causal directions.**
From the perspective of UNICEF, the world’s leading agency for children, setting an online age of majority does not protect children from online risks. ... “Evidence shows that risks and opportunities are shaped by factors such as digital literacy, parental support, and platform design — not age alone,” she told *EU Perspectives*. ... UNICEF research shows that older adolescents often face greater exposure to harmful content and exploitation than younger children, and that children’s evolving capacities “vary widely even within the same age group”. As a result, Ms Johnson warns that age limits risk, creating a false sense of protection. ... The latest research by UNICEF and INTERPOL finds that social media platforms “remain a primary setting that facilitates online sexual abuse, by a significant margin, compared to other platforms”. ... UNICEF data confirms that harmful online experiences can have serious psychological consequences, but also highlights why blanket restrictions may miss the mark. The UNICEF report analysed data from 21 countries and found that children who experience online sexual abuse or online bullying show “significantly higher levels of anxiety, more suicidal thoughts and behaviours, and are more likely to self-harm”. Exposure to harmful content and repeated negative online experiences also has a measurable negative impact on children’s well-being. ... Instead, the organisation calls for governments and companies “to meet their responsibilities: redesigning platforms and policies around children’s rights and safety, and deploying rights-respecting age-assurance tools”. ... This includes “the rights to safety, participation, inclusion, access to information, and privacy.”
Across reviews, general SMU showed weak and inconsistent associations with both well‐being and ill‐being, while problematic SMU was consistently linked to ill‐being.
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine; Health and Medicine Division; Board on Population Health and Public Health Practice; Committee on the Impact of Social Media on Adolescent Health; Editors: Alexis Wojtowicz, Gillian J. Buckley, and Sandro Galea. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2024 Mar 25. ... Social media has been fully integrated into the lives of most adolescents in the U.S., raising concerns among parents, physicians, public health officials, and others about its effect on mental and physical health. Over the past year, an ad hoc committee of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine examined the research and produced this detailed report exploring that effect and laying out recommendations for policymakers, regulators, industry, and others in an effort to maximize the good and minimize the bad. Focus areas include platform design, transparency and accountability, digital media literacy among young people and adults, online harassment, and supporting researchers. ... National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2024. *Social media and adolescent health*. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/27396.
On **17 and 18 November 2026** two reports described an amendment to Italy's security decree (*decreto sicurezza*) that would bar **under-13s** from holding a social-media account, keep the accounts of **13- to 15-year-olds linked to a parent's or guardian's account**, and allow a profile of one's own from **16**. ... law.** The amendment had not been tabled when the reports went out, we have not read its text, and nothing here is due from a small shop, forum or game. ... Italy already has a digital age, and it is not 13 and not 16. The **Garante per la protezione dei dati personali** — the data-protection authority — states on its own pages that in Italy the threshold is **14**, under `art. 2-quinquies` of **d.lgs. 196/2003**, the *Codice privacy*. The GDPR lets member states set it between 13 and 16 for consent to information-society services; Italy chose 14. - **What the 14 means** From 14 a minor may consent **on their own** to the processing of personal data for digital services; below 14, parental authorisation is needed. That is a rule about **consent to processing**. ... "Social media platforms" and "social network platforms" are the only descriptions.
# Banning something does not mean eliminating it. The risk of banning social media for minors The majority is proposing new restrictions on minors’ access to social media. An amendment to the security decree, with Fabio Rampelli (Fratelli d’Italia) as the lead signatory, provides for a ban on children under 13, accounts linked to those of their parents until the age of 16, and independent access thereafter. Platforms will be required to verify age in accordance with procedures laid down by AGCOM.
No longer just the permission of mom or dad: to open a social media profile, a teenager may have to maintain a connection with their parents' account until the age of 16. ... For those under 13, however, registration would be prohibited. ... The announced framework includes a ban on registration for those under 13, a profile linked to that of the parents for those aged 13 to 16, and the possibility of opening an independent account from the age of 16. ... The first point to clarify concerns a distinction often overlooked: consent to data processing and the right to register for a social network are not the same thing. The Data Protection Authority reminds us that in Italy a minor can independently express consent when this is the legal basis for processing for the direct offer of digital services, starting from 14 years. Before that, the authorization of the person exercising parental responsibility is required. This regulation does not, by itself, equate to a general ban on access below that threshold. The announced proposal would therefore introduce a different constraint: not only the consent of the adult but also the impossibility of having an independent account until the age of 16.
# L’Italia si appresta a introdurre restrizioni sui social media per gli adolescenti • Children below the age of 13 will be barred from having social media accounts.
# Italy Data protection oversight sits with the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, which plays a central role in enforcing child safety obligations online. ... Under Italian law, the digital age of consent is 14. Children under 14 cannot validly consent to the processing of their personal data without parental authorisation. This has practical implications for online services: - Services relying on consent must be able to determine whether users are at least 14 - Platforms that do not know a user’s age cannot safely assume valid consent ... While Italian law sets a minimum age of 14 for valid data-processing consent, authorities have taken a broader approach to social media platforms where under-age access presents foreseeable risks. The Garante has taken enforcement action where: - Children under 14 were able to register without effective age checks - Platforms enabled profiling of minors without lawful consent Regulatory decisions have emphasised that: - Terms and conditions alone are insufficient - Platforms must take reasonable steps to verify age where risks to children are foreseeable
The decision turns posting a child's photo from a casual parental habit into an act that needs both parents' prior consent when the child is under 14, and it rejects the three defenses parents reach for first: affection, a small number of photos, and a private profile. ... According to the Garante's decision no. 314 of April 29, 2026, a father filed a complaint after his ex-wife published photographs of their two children, both under 14, on her Facebook profile without his consent. ... Its core statement is that publishing images of minors on social networks "requires the prior consent of both parents" (in Italian, "il preventivo consenso di entrambi i genitori"). It issued an **ammonimento**, a formal warning, and prohibited the mother from further publishing the children's images on social networks without both parents' consent. The legal basis it cited includes GDPR articles 5(1)(a) (lawfulness, fairness and transparency), 6(1)(a) (consent) and 8 (children's consent), together with article 2-quinquies of the Italian Privacy Code, which sets the digital-consent age at 14. ... In Italy the age of digital consent is 14, and the Garante's reasoning treats children under 14 as needing both parents' prior consent. Under GDPR Article 8 the default age is 16, and each member state may lower it to no less than 13.
Italy is getting ready to implement tougher rules limiting children's use of social media, including a proposed ban on accounts for children under 13 and required parental supervision for teens between 13 and 15. ... These measures form part of an amendment to a security decree that is currently under discussion in the Italian parliament and are anticipated to be approved by late December 2026. The proposed rules would create varying levels of access according to a user's age, with the goal of curbing independent social media use among younger children. Children under the age of 13 would be entirely barred from holding social media accounts. For teenagers between 13 and 15, access would be allowed only via accounts linked to their parents' accounts, giving parents a larger role in overseeing their children's online activity. Users aged 16 and older would be permitted to register and manage independent accounts without the proposed parental-linking requirement. The exemption for educational applications would let children keep using digital services designed for learning and education. ... A key component of the proposed legislation is the obligation for social media companies to verify their users' ages. As part of the amendment, Italy's telecommunications regulator, AGCOM, would be responsible for drawing up guidelines on age verification within nine months of the decree taking effect. ... Nevertheless, the restrictions should not yet be regarded as enacted law. How they are implemented will hinge on the legislative process and on the final wording of the provisions that are approved.
Judges had been expected to rule on Thursday but postponed the hearing until January 21, lawyers involved in the case said, after the Italian government said on Wednesday it expected parliament to approve a decree restricting minors' access to social media by the end of the year. ... The class injunctive action, a collective lawsuit filed by MOIGE, an Italian parents' association, asks the court to require the companies, which operate Facebook, Instagram and TikTok, to adopt stronger age-verification systems for users under 14. ... The plans include an amendment to a security decree, proposed earlier this week by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's ruling coalition, that would bar children under 13 from holding social media accounts. ... *Copyright Reuters or USA Today Network via Reuters Connect.*
### Delibera AGCOM n. 96/25/CONS dell'8 aprile 2025 (technical and process rules for age verification) Adopts the binding technical and process rules that website managers and video-sharing platform providers must use to verify users are adults before granting access to pornographic content, using a dual anonymity model with independent certified third party verifiers so that neither the verifier nor the site learns both the user's identity and the service accessed. Providers established in Italy had six months from publication, until 12 November 2025, to comply; AGCOM issued a list of covered sites in a communication of 31 October 2025. AGCOM's published guidance gives the same date, 12 November 2025, for providers established outside the European Union, and 1 February 2026 for providers established in another Member State.
## Are the technological and regulatory tools required to enforce a ban available or likely to be adequate? In 2025, both Apple and Google introduced privacy-preserving age assurance mechanisms at the device level. ... ## Recommendations (a) Introduce a minimum age of 16 for social media account creation, predicated on the presence of harmful design features in platforms, thereby incentivising safer product design. (b) Require platforms to adopt privacy-preserving age assurance mechanisms at both the device and application levels.
## Jonathan Haidt on How To Lead a Happy Life Before then, just give your kid a flip phone, or in elementary school a landline. No smartphone before high school, no social media before sixteen, just delay it till sixteen. ... Battle number two is to get kids off social media, at least to delay it till 16. ... I am opposed to content-based restrictions and regulations, and I am opposed to age verification methods, or mandating age verification methods that also give more about your identity, when all we need is age.
# Online Age Verification Has Guaranteed Costs and Uncertain Benefits ## The Costs of Age Verification 3. **Data-Breach and Privacy Risks**: Age verification can require users to provide sensitive information such as IDs, financial information, or biometrics that could be exposed in a breach. 4. **Restricted Access to Lawful Information for Users**: By requiring age verification to access various platforms, constitutionally protected speech on those platforms that ranges from news and political commentary to educational and self-help materials is restricted. ... 6. **Weakened Role of Parents**: Age-verification policies shift authority from families to government, weakening parents’ ability to make decisions related to young people’s access to information and media consumption. ... ### Restricted Access to Lawful Information for Users Age-verification laws in the US would almost certainly be deemed to violate the First Amendment, except in the case of pornography or other adult sexual content. ... ### Weakened Role of Parents Another cost of age verification is the loss of parental freedom. Proponents of age verification argue that restricting free expression is necessary to create a safe and moral space for kids online. ... By inserting the government into matters of online speech, parental freedom is diminished, not enhanced. Laws restricting social media force families to obey the government’s rules imposed through liability-averse platforms, and they could create a slippery slope that allows the government to dictate parental decisions about information and media more generally.^32^ Communities and governments can protect children from objective harms by helping educate kids and parents about how to be safe online and offline and by arresting predators and fraudsters. This would still leave essential moral and parenting decisions in the hands of parents.^33^ In this sense, liberty is compatible with parents who wish to instill a certain version of moral virtue in their children.
# Social Media Laws Could End Anonymous Speech Online Without Making Anyone Safer Recently, the House of Representatives passed the KIDS Act, an omnibus package of bills that could fundamentally change how all users experience the internet. This approach puts policymakers, not parents, in control of what their children see online. And it threatens speech and privacy rights for adult users, too. ... The KIDS Act combines a range of proposals that set new restrictions on everything from social media and messaging apps to video games and chatbots for kids and teens. ... Because of the heightened standards, however, many companies will begin to engage in age verification for all users, even though it is not required, to avoid potential liability. ... The United Kingdom, for example, recently made headlines by moving to bar anyone under 16 from using social media and advanced a raft of further restrictions: government-mandated app curfews for 16- and 17-year-olds, along with a plethora of potential new regulations on everything from AI chatbots to messaging apps. In effect, the UK has placed the government between users and the internet, dictating how much screen time and what information a person may access unless they first prove who they are. Australia banned under-16s from social media in late 2025, and similar bans have been considered in countries ranging from France to Malaysia. ... But such bans harm more than just young users. Rules that require age verification mean that adults, too, will have to prove they are of age to engage in any covered activity online, whether asking a chatbot a question or posting on social media. A gate built to keep children out is, by necessity, a checkpoint that everyone must pass through — but not before surrendering their personal identification at the door, which the platform will keep. As such, they create privacy vulnerabilities for all internet users.
He’s been on a global mission to educate parents, the media, and government officials about the harms that social media companies inflict on children. He believes that the world ran a huge uncontrolled experiment on kids in the 2010s by giving them smartphones and social media accounts. And now, there is clear evidence – often through court case disclosure – that the experiment has harmed children, and that it’s time to call it off. Haidt has been calling on governments to ban social media for those under 16. And they’re listening. Canada is reportedly considering one for kids under 14 right now.
Several countries have enacted youth social media bans, with dozens more considering similar legislation, including chatbot bans, despite insufficient supporting evidence. Experts criticize the rushed nature of legislation that leaves compliance gaps, pushes youth to less safe alternatives, and poses safety and privacy concerns. ... In 2025, Australia passed legislation banning youth under 16 from social media. Since then, France , Indonesia , Malaysia , and some US states have enacted similar restrictions. ... The laws tap into anxiety over youth social media use — brought to the forefront by Jonathan Haidt ’ s book, The Anxious Generation , which some experts have criticized for its lack of scientific accuracy — as well as distrust over big tech companies. Social scientists warn that these bans don ’ t work and that they may drive youth to less regulated platforms to evade age restrictions. ... While countries continue rolling out bans and restrictions, growing evidence suggests these may be ineffective and may potentially harm those they aim to protect. Regulators will need to work with researchers to understand the scope of potential risk, regulate tech companies without impinging on rights or access to information, and work toward building holistic policy to support youth.
Researchers recently interviewed 25,000 teenagers over three years in Manchester, I believe, and they found that there were no effects at the population level for worse mental health outcomes. ... Giving these arbitrary numbers - the no phones until 14 and the no social media until 16 - there are plenty of exceptions to that, and it really depends on the family and on the individual maturity of children, right? Parents know best what their children are going to be doing. ... And the answer is yes, but it's a small effect, and then we fight over whether it's big enough. ... And we were just talking to social psychologist Jonathan Haidt, who thinks we need to keep kids off social media entirely, at least until the age of 16.
The common feature of these rules is that they restrict how users can use these services and tools, diminishing their value, increasing the possibility of privacy violations or identity theft, or both. ... Nothing in this section pertains to a private company’s independent decision to build parental controls into its product. Many companies have already developed tools within their software that give parents direct control over their child’s use of a device. Yet when it comes to parents’ decisions about the appropriate use of technology, some states have placed themselves between the parent and child, passing laws that ban certain tools, social media apps, and web services for minors, even if the parents would otherwise have authorized them. Those types of restrictions are also measured here. ... Age-verification mandates for apps and social media are sold as a way to protect kids, but they burden everyone: The only way to prove someone is not under 18 is to prove they are 18 or older. So, as a practical matter, every user, adult or teen, must provide a government identification number, a face scan, or other personal data simply to get online. That creates new privacy and security risks since sensitive data collected and stored by platforms or third-party verifiers become a target for hackers. It also chills free expression by ending anonymous speech. It is true that not every form of age verification is equally intrusive, so states that require the provision of sensitive information, particularly a government identification number, receive the full 2‑point deduction.
Australia has become the first nation to ban social media for children under 16, citing concerns over online dangers and mental health impacts. ... Beginning Dec. 10, social platforms such as TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, Reddit, Snapchat and YouTube are required to prevent underage users from accessing their services. ... Social psychologist Jonathan Haidt has spent years warning about the consequences of early social media exposure. In his book The Anxious Generation, he argues that smartphones should be restricted before age 14 and social media before age 16.
No. 2 - no social media before 16. ... Researchers recently interviewed 25,000 teenagers over three years in Manchester, I believe, and they found that there were no effects at the population level for worse mental health outcomes. ... Giving these arbitrary numbers - the no phones until 14 and the no social media until 16 - there are plenty of exceptions to that, and it really depends on the family and on the individual maturity of children, right? Parents know best what their children are going to be doing. ... And the answer is yes, but it's a small effect, and then we fight over whether it's big enough. ... And we were just talking to social psychologist Jonathan Haidt, who thinks we need to keep kids off social media entirely, at least until the age of 16.
Indeed, age verification proposals, sold as a way to protect kids online, are spreading worldwide, rom Australia's under-16 social media ban to various U.S. proposals, that would effectively require ID checks to use online platforms or any phone or computer app. Each one puts more personal information at risk of hacks and breaches. ... Breaches don't just enable fraud. They also threaten anonymous speech. Much of the internet is accessed anonymously or pseudonymously. Many social media platforms allow users to speak and receive information through accounts that are not tied to their real names. Most apps, from The New York Times to Signal to Pokémon Go, don't require users to show ID. If you must show ID to speak online, your identity is one breach away from being made public. ... After the country banned kids from holding social media accounts, many simply evaded enforcement. Instead of staying on platforms with parental controls and algorithms that at least try to limit some types of inappropriate content, many kids moved to platforms without those protections. Others faked their ages, so platforms treated them as adults. In the UK, their media regulator charged with overseeing their Online Safety Act recently concluded that the law made "no significant change in the proportion children encountering harmful content." ... Privacy and freedom online are an unacceptable price for a policy that fails kids and turns everyone's data into a target.
Sign up to read the full research briefing
Sign up